Alecomm · Parliamentary Accountability

Public View · Owner Sign-In

Economics References Committee; Reference

Public Concern: Parliamentary proposal recorded under Committees: Economics References Committee; Reference.

Requested Action: That the following matter be referred to the Economics References Committee for inquiry and report by the last sitting day in March 2025: The reasons for the collapse of wealth management companies, and the implications for the establishment of the Compensation Scheme of Last Resort ( CSLR ) and challenges to its ongoing sustainability, with particular reference to Dixon Advisory & Superannuation Services Pty Limited (Dixon Advisory) as an example, and: (a) the underlying cause of the collapse of wealth management companies such as Dixon Advisory, including the business model and influence of the sale of related party products, for example the US Master Residential Property Fund; (b) how the actions of directors of wealth management companies and related entities, senior management and the individual advisers contribute to the collapse of these companies; (c) the role of the financial services regulatory regime in the context of how matters involving the collapse of an investment product promoted by a vertically integrated business are assessed and how fault is attributed; (d) evaluation of the placement of wealth management companies into administration and the related insolvency issues, including with respect to the appropriateness of actions by directors and senior management and the transfer of advisers and clients to a related party entity for no consideration; (e) assessment of the period for which wealth management companies can remain a member of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority ; (f) the role of Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), including providing consumer information to investors affected by corporate collapse and consideration of the most appropriate arrangements for future cases of insolvency; (g) ASIC's role investigating corporate collapse and the appropriateness of any regulatory intervention that may reduce scale of loss for consumers; (h) options for enforcement action, including litigation, that ASIC has available to it in relation to wealth management companies following collapse; (i) the implications of the collapse of wealth management companies on the establishment of the CSLR, including with respect to design considerations and the potential implications for future matters; and (j) any other related matters.

Effect On The Original Proposal: Recorded outcomes and any procedural decisions are shown separately for each question.

Original Question Vote: 2024-09-17 · Substantive Proposal · Carried: 29 For, 19 Against

Debate Opportunity: The originating contribution and related proceedings are linked in Sources.

Original Proposal
That the following matter be referred to the Economics References Committee for inquiry and report by the last sitting day in March 2025: The reasons for the collapse of wealth management companies, and the implications for the establishment of the Compensation Scheme of Last Resort ( CSLR ) and challenges to its ongoing sustainability, with particular reference to Dixon Advisory & Superannuation Services Pty Limited (Dixon Advisory) as an example, and: (a) the underlying cause of the collapse of wealth management companies such as Dixon Advisory, including the business model and influence of the sale of related party products, for example the US Master Residential Property Fund; (b) how the actions of directors of wealth management companies and related entities, senior management and the individual advisers contribute to the collapse of these companies; (c) the role of the financial services regulatory regime in the context of how matters involving the collapse of an investment product promoted by a vertically integrated business are assessed and how fault is attributed; (d) evaluation of the placement of wealth management companies into administration and the related insolvency issues, including with respect to the appropriateness of actions by directors and senior management and the transfer of advisers and clients to a related party entity for no consideration; (e) assessment of the period for which wealth management companies can remain a member of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority ; (f) the role of Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), including providing consumer information to investors affected by corporate collapse and consideration of the most appropriate arrangements for future cases of insolvency; (g) ASIC's role investigating corporate collapse and the appropriateness of any regulatory intervention that may reduce scale of loss for consumers; (h) options for enforcement action, including litigation, that ASIC has available to it in relation to wealth management companies following collapse; (i) the implications of the collapse of wealth management companies on the establishment of the CSLR, including with respect to design considerations and the potential implications for future matters; and (j) any other related matters.

Sponsors / Representatives: Pauline Hanson

Outcome: Carried: 29 For, 19 Against

Type: Committee Referral

Chamber: Senate

Jurisdiction: Australian Parliament, Australia

Recorded Date: 17/09/2024

Topics: Pauline Hanson; Committee Referral; Committees

Votes And Procedural Actions

Substantive Proposal · Adopt Proposal

Date: 2024-09-17

Exact Question Put: The question is that the amendment moved by Senator Chisholm to business of the Senate No.

Result: Carried: 29 For, 19 Against

Effect: This vote concerns the exact question and stage shown above.

Division / Decision Reference: Senate/2024-09-17/4

For: 29 · Against: 19

Named roll-call entries: 48. Names omitted from the recorded roll call have no inferred vote.

Showing 48 Of 48 Named Votes

Senator / MPParty At The TimeState / ElectorateVotePublished Explanation
Andrew McLachlanSenatorNot RecordedSAForNot Recorded
Anne RustonSenatorLiberal PartySAForNot Recorded
Anne UrquhartSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASForNot Recorded
Anthony ChisholmSenatorAustralian Labor PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Barbara PocockSenatorAustralian GreensSAAgainstNot Recorded
Catryna BilykSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASForNot Recorded
Claire ChandlerSenatorLiberal PartyTASForNot Recorded
Dave SharmaSenatorLiberal PartyNSWForNot Recorded
David PocockSenatorIndependentACTAgainstNot Recorded
David ShoebridgeSenatorAustralian GreensNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Dean SmithSenatorLiberal PartyWAForNot Recorded
Deborah O'NeillSenatorAustralian Labor PartyNSWForNot Recorded
Don FarrellSenatorAustralian Labor PartySAForNot Recorded
Dorinda CoxSenatorAustralian GreensWAAgainstNot Recorded
Gerard RennickSenatorNot RecordedQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Glenn SterleSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAForNot Recorded
Jacqui LambieSenatorJacqui Lambie NetworkTASAgainstNot Recorded
Jana StewartSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICForNot Recorded
Jenny McAllisterSenatorAustralian Labor PartyNSWForNot Recorded
Jess WalshSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICForNot Recorded
Jonathon DuniamSenatorLiberal PartyTASForNot Recorded
Jordon Steele-JohnSenatorAustralian GreensWAAgainstNot Recorded
Karen GroganSenatorAustralian Labor PartySAForNot Recorded
Larissa WatersSenatorAustralian GreensQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Lidia ThorpeSenatorIndependentVICAgainstNot Recorded
Lisa DarmaninSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICForNot Recorded
Louise PrattSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAForNot Recorded
Malcolm RobertsSenatorPauline Hanson's One Nation PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Maria KovacicSenatorLiberal PartyNSWForNot Recorded
Marielle SmithSenatorAustralian Labor PartySAForNot Recorded
Matt O'SullivanSenatorLiberal PartyWAForNot Recorded
Mehreen FaruqiSenatorAustralian GreensNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Michaelia CashSenatorLiberal PartyWAForNot Recorded
Nick McKimSenatorAustralian GreensTASAgainstNot Recorded
Pauline HansonSenatorPauline Hanson's One Nation PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Penny Allman-PayneSenatorAustralian GreensQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Perin DaveySenatorNational PartyNSWForNot Recorded
Peter Whish-WilsonSenatorAustralian GreensTASAgainstNot Recorded
Raff CicconeSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICForNot Recorded
Ralph BabetSenatorUnited Australia PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Richard ColbeckSenatorLiberal PartyTASForNot Recorded
Sarah Hanson-YoungSenatorAustralian GreensSAAgainstNot Recorded
Steph Hodgins-MaySenatorAustralian GreensVICAgainstNot Recorded
Sue LinesSenatorNot RecordedWAForNot Recorded
Tammy TyrrellSenatorIndependentTASAgainstNot Recorded
Tony SheldonSenatorAustralian Labor PartyNSWForNot Recorded
Varun GhoshSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAForNot Recorded
Wendy AskewSenatorLiberal PartyTASForNot Recorded

Coverage Notes: Individual votes are included only for matched named roll calls. Unlisted people have no inferred vote. Parties and state labels are those in the division source.

Reference: 4PQ4-U97M-CZTG-GB6K