Alecomm · Parliamentary Accountability

Public View · Owner Sign-In

Community Affairs References Committee; Reference

Public Concern: Parliamentary proposal recorded under Committees: Community Affairs References Committee; Reference.

Requested Action: That the following matter be referred to the Community Affairs References Committee for inquiry and report by 7 October 2024: The practice and governance surrounding the prescription of puberty blockers to children in Australia, with particular reference to: (a) the adequacy of the evidence base supporting the safety and clinical effectiveness of puberty blockers as a treatment option for children experiencing gender dysphoria, including an examination of international developments and decisions, such as the move by United Kingdom ( UK ) health authorities to ban the routine prescription of puberty blockers to young teenagers; (b) the transparency and accessibility of outcome data from Australian children's hospitals and gender services on the long-term impacts of puberty blockers on children, including but not limited to brain development, bone mineral density, future fertility and sexual function, as well as mental health outcomes; (c) the consistency of Australia's approach to the prescription of puberty blockers with international best practices and the evolving global understanding of their risks and benefits, including a comparison with policies in the UK, the Netherlands, Norway, Finland, and other countries that have recently revisited their stance on gender-affirming care; (d) the processes and criteria used by Australian health services, including the Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne and others, in deciding to initiate puberty blocker treatment, with an emphasis on the exploration of psychological complexities and the consideration of alternative treatments; (e) the role of professional consensus and the development of national standards of care in the absence of long-term outcome data, and the impact of these standards on clinical governance and decision-making processes; (f) the views and experiences of patients, families, clinicians, and other stakeholders directly affected by the prescription of puberty blockers, including the adequacy of informed consent processes and the support provided to patients and families; (g) the response of Australian medical bodies and health departments to international critiques and recommendations regarding puberty blockers and gender-affirming care; (h) the impact of social transition as the beginning of the child gender-affirmation process, including pressures on educators and health professionals to affirm preferred pronouns and identities, with a focus on the approach's potential harm and the need for reconsideration; and (i) any related matters.

Effect On The Original Proposal: Recorded outcomes and any procedural decisions are shown separately for each question.

Original Question Vote: 2024-03-20 · Substantive Proposal · DEFEATED: 25 For, 30 Against

Debate Opportunity: The originating contribution and related proceedings are linked in Sources.

Original Proposal
That the following matter be referred to the Community Affairs References Committee for inquiry and report by 7 October 2024: The practice and governance surrounding the prescription of puberty blockers to children in Australia, with particular reference to: (a) the adequacy of the evidence base supporting the safety and clinical effectiveness of puberty blockers as a treatment option for children experiencing gender dysphoria, including an examination of international developments and decisions, such as the move by United Kingdom ( UK ) health authorities to ban the routine prescription of puberty blockers to young teenagers; (b) the transparency and accessibility of outcome data from Australian children's hospitals and gender services on the long-term impacts of puberty blockers on children, including but not limited to brain development, bone mineral density, future fertility and sexual function, as well as mental health outcomes; (c) the consistency of Australia's approach to the prescription of puberty blockers with international best practices and the evolving global understanding of their risks and benefits, including a comparison with policies in the UK, the Netherlands, Norway, Finland, and other countries that have recently revisited their stance on gender-affirming care; (d) the processes and criteria used by Australian health services, including the Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne and others, in deciding to initiate puberty blocker treatment, with an emphasis on the exploration of psychological complexities and the consideration of alternative treatments; (e) the role of professional consensus and the development of national standards of care in the absence of long-term outcome data, and the impact of these standards on clinical governance and decision-making processes; (f) the views and experiences of patients, families, clinicians, and other stakeholders directly affected by the prescription of puberty blockers, including the adequacy of informed consent processes and the support provided to patients and families; (g) the response of Australian medical bodies and health departments to international critiques and recommendations regarding puberty blockers and gender-affirming care; (h) the impact of social transition as the beginning of the child gender-affirmation process, including pressures on educators and health professionals to affirm preferred pronouns and identities, with a focus on the approach's potential harm and the need for reconsideration; and (i) any related matters.

Sponsors / Representatives: Pauline Hanson

Outcome: DEFEATED: 25 For, 30 Against

Type: Committee Referral

Chamber: Senate

Jurisdiction: Australian Parliament, Australia

Recorded Date: 20/03/2024

Topics: Pauline Hanson; Committee Referral; Committees

Votes And Procedural Actions

Substantive Proposal · Adopt Proposal

Date: 2024-03-20

Exact Question Put: The question is that business of the Senate notice of motion No.

Result: DEFEATED: 25 For, 30 Against

Effect: This vote concerns the exact question and stage shown above.

Division / Decision Reference: Senate/2024-03-20/6

For: 25 · Against: 30

Named roll-call entries: 55. Names omitted from the recorded roll call have no inferred vote.

Showing 55 Of 55 Named Votes

Senator / MPParty At The TimeState / ElectorateVotePublished Explanation
Alex AnticSenatorLiberal PartySAForNot Recorded
Anne RustonSenatorLiberal PartySAForNot Recorded
Anne UrquhartSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Anthony ChisholmSenatorAustralian Labor PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Barbara PocockSenatorAustralian GreensSAAgainstNot Recorded
Carol BrownSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Catryna BilykSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Claire ChandlerSenatorLiberal PartyTASForNot Recorded
Dave SharmaSenatorLiberal PartyNSWForNot Recorded
David FawcettSenatorLiberal PartySAForNot Recorded
David PocockSenatorIndependentACTAgainstNot Recorded
David ShoebridgeSenatorAustralian GreensNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Dorinda CoxSenatorAustralian GreensWAAgainstNot Recorded
Fatima PaymanSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Gerard RennickSenatorLiberal PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Glenn SterleSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Helen PolleySenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Hollie HughesSenatorLiberal PartyNSWForNot Recorded
Jacinta Nampijinpa PriceSenatorCountry Liberal PartyNTForNot Recorded
James McGrathSenatorLiberal National PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Janet RiceSenatorAustralian GreensVICAgainstNot Recorded
Jess WalshSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Jonathon DuniamSenatorLiberal PartyTASForNot Recorded
Jordon Steele-JohnSenatorAustralian GreensWAAgainstNot Recorded
Karen GroganSenatorAustralian Labor PartySAAgainstNot Recorded
Katy GallagherSenatorAustralian Labor PartyACTAgainstNot Recorded
Kerrynne LiddleSenatorLiberal PartySAForNot Recorded
Larissa WatersSenatorAustralian GreensQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Lidia ThorpeSenatorIndependentVICAgainstNot Recorded
Linda ReynoldsSenatorLiberal PartyWAForNot Recorded
Louise PrattSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Malcolm RobertsSenatorPauline Hanson's One Nation PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Maria KovacicSenatorLiberal PartyNSWForNot Recorded
Marielle SmithSenatorAustralian Labor PartySAAgainstNot Recorded
Matt O'SullivanSenatorLiberal PartyWAForNot Recorded
Matthew CanavanSenatorLiberal National PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Mehreen FaruqiSenatorAustralian GreensNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Michaelia CashSenatorLiberal PartyWAForNot Recorded
Nick McKimSenatorAustralian GreensTASAgainstNot Recorded
Nita GreenSenatorAustralian Labor PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Paul ScarrSenatorLiberal PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Pauline HansonSenatorPauline Hanson's One Nation PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Penny Allman-PayneSenatorAustralian GreensQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Perin DaveySenatorNational PartyNSWForNot Recorded
Peter Whish-WilsonSenatorAustralian GreensTASAgainstNot Recorded
Raff CicconeSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Ralph BabetSenatorUnited Australia PartyVICForNot Recorded
Ross CadellSenatorNational PartyNSWForNot Recorded
Sarah Hanson-YoungSenatorAustralian GreensSAAgainstNot Recorded
Sarah HendersonSenatorLiberal PartyVICForNot Recorded
Sue LinesSenatorNot RecordedWAAgainstNot Recorded
Susan McDonaldSenatorNational PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Tony SheldonSenatorAustralian Labor PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Varun GhoshSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Wendy AskewSenatorLiberal PartyTASForNot Recorded

Coverage Notes: Individual votes are included only for matched named roll calls. Unlisted people have no inferred vote. Parties and state labels are those in the division source.

Reference: A7BQ-HCH7-7QT4-ZN3Y