Alecomm · Parliamentary Accountability

Public View · Owner Sign-In

Banking and Financial Services

Public Concern: Parliamentary proposal recorded under Motions: Banking and Financial Services.

Requested Action: That the Senate: (a) notes that: (i) trust in banks is essential to the economy, (ii) trust in the banks has been undermined by adverse findings of the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, (iii) misconduct related to poor standards of mortgage lending affects all Australians and risks financial instability, (iv) concentration on mortgage lending makes the economy vulnerable to a downturn in the housing market, (v) reliance on overseas debt markets for short-term borrowing by the major banks, and contagion from overseas counterparties through trillions of dollars of derivatives related to mortgages, pose serious systemic risk, (vi) misconduct related to financial advice, small business lending, superannuation and insurance shows that the business model of major banks is based on exploitation rather than customer service, (vii) the integrated structure of banks facilitates misconduct due to the lack of transparency when traditional commercial banking is linked with investment banking, financial advice, wealth management, stockbroking, superannuation and insurance businesses, (viii) the integrated structure creates a conflict of interests because the lack of transparency enables banks to extract profits through cross-subsidies of various activities, and the indirect cost to retail superannuation members runs to many billions per year, (ix) the enormous profits extracted through the integrated structure entrenches the major banks as an effective cartel, preventing market competition and increasing concentration, and (x) the integrated structure puts bank deposits at risk as collateral for major banks' speculation in mortgage-backed securities and derivatives – this puts the real productive economy at unnecessary risk; and (b) calls on the Federal Government to reduce the conflicts of interests by legislating the structural separation of the banking system, where traditional commercial banking of taking deposits and making loans is separated from investment banking and all other financial services, including financial advice, wealth management, superannuation, stockbroking and insurance.

Effect On The Original Proposal: Recorded outcomes and any procedural decisions are shown separately for each question.

Original Question Vote: 2018-10-18 · Substantive Proposal · DEFEATED: 15 For, 31 Against

Debate Opportunity: The originating contribution and related proceedings are linked in Sources.

Original Proposal
That the Senate: (a) notes that: (i) trust in banks is essential to the economy, (ii) trust in the banks has been undermined by adverse findings of the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, (iii) misconduct related to poor standards of mortgage lending affects all Australians and risks financial instability, (iv) concentration on mortgage lending makes the economy vulnerable to a downturn in the housing market, (v) reliance on overseas debt markets for short-term borrowing by the major banks, and contagion from overseas counterparties through trillions of dollars of derivatives related to mortgages, pose serious systemic risk, (vi) misconduct related to financial advice, small business lending, superannuation and insurance shows that the business model of major banks is based on exploitation rather than customer service, (vii) the integrated structure of banks facilitates misconduct due to the lack of transparency when traditional commercial banking is linked with investment banking, financial advice, wealth management, stockbroking, superannuation and insurance businesses, (viii) the integrated structure creates a conflict of interests because the lack of transparency enables banks to extract profits through cross-subsidies of various activities, and the indirect cost to retail superannuation members runs to many billions per year, (ix) the enormous profits extracted through the integrated structure entrenches the major banks as an effective cartel, preventing market competition and increasing concentration, and (x) the integrated structure puts bank deposits at risk as collateral for major banks' speculation in mortgage-backed securities and derivatives – this puts the real productive economy at unnecessary risk; and (b) calls on the Federal Government to reduce the conflicts of interests by legislating the structural separation of the banking system, where traditional commercial banking of taking deposits and making loans is separated from investment banking and all other financial services, including financial advice, wealth management, superannuation, stockbroking and insurance.

Sponsors / Representatives: Pauline Hanson

Outcome: DEFEATED: 15 For, 31 Against

Type: Motion

Chamber: Senate

Jurisdiction: Australian Parliament, Australia

Recorded Date: 18/10/2018

Topics: Pauline Hanson; Motion; Motions

Votes And Procedural Actions

Substantive Proposal · Adopt Proposal

Date: 2018-10-18

Exact Question Put: That the Senate: (a) notes that: (i) trust in banks is essential to the economy, (ii) trust in the banks has been undermined by adverse findings of the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, (iii) misconduct related to poor standards of mortgage lending affects all Australians and risks financial instability, (iv) concentration on mortgage lending makes the economy vulnerable to a downturn in the housing market, (v) reliance on overseas debt markets for short-term borrowing by the major banks, and contagion from overseas counterparties through trillions of dollars of derivatives related to mortgages, pose serious systemic risk, (vi) misconduct related to financial advice, small business lending, superannuation and insurance shows that the business model of major banks is based on exploitation rather than customer service, (vii) the integrated structure of banks facilitates misconduct due to the lack of transparency when traditional commercial banking is linked with investment banking, financial advice, wealth management, stockbroking, superannuation and insurance businesses, (viii) the integrated structure creates a conflict of interests because the lack of transparency enables banks to extract profits through cross-subsidies of various activities, and the indirect cost to retail superannuation members runs to many billions per year, (ix) the enormous profits extracted through the integrated structure entrenches the major banks as an effective cartel, preventing market competition and increasing concentration, and (x) the integrated structure puts bank deposits at risk as collateral for major banks' speculation in mortgage-backed securities and derivatives – this puts the real productive economy at unnecessary risk; and

Result: DEFEATED: 15 For, 31 Against

Effect: This vote concerns the exact question and stage shown above.

Division / Decision Reference: Senate/2018-10-18/7

For: 15 · Against: 31

Named roll-call entries: 46. Names omitted from the recorded roll call have no inferred vote.

Showing 46 Of 46 Named Votes

Senator / MPParty At The TimeState / ElectorateVotePublished Explanation
Alex GallacherSenatorAustralian Labor PartySAAgainstNot Recorded
Amanda StokerSenatorLiberal PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Anne UrquhartSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Anthony ChisholmSenatorAustralian Labor PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Barry O'SullivanSenatorNational PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Catryna BilykSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Concetta Fierravanti-WellsSenatorLiberal PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
David BushbySenatorLiberal PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
David LeyonhjelmSenatorNot RecordedNSWAgainstNot Recorded
David SmithSenatorAustralian Labor PartyACTAgainstNot Recorded
Deborah O'NeillSenatorAustralian Labor PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Derryn HinchSenatorNot RecordedVICAgainstNot Recorded
Fraser AnningSenatorNot RecordedQLDForNot Recorded
Gavin MarshallSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Glenn SterleSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Jacinta CollinsSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
James McGrathSenatorLiberal National PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
James PatersonSenatorLiberal PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Jane HumeSenatorLiberal PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Janet RiceSenatorAustralian GreensVICForNot Recorded
Jim MolanSenatorLiberal PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
John WilliamsSenatorNational PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Jonathon DuniamSenatorLiberal PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Kristina KeneallySenatorAustralian Labor PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Larissa WatersSenatorAustralian GreensQLDForNot Recorded
Linda ReynoldsSenatorLiberal PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Lisa SinghSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Louise PrattSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Mehreen FaruqiSenatorAustralian GreensNSWForNot Recorded
Mitch FifieldSenatorLiberal PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Murray WattSenatorAustralian Labor PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Nick McKimSenatorAustralian GreensTASForNot Recorded
Nigel ScullionSenatorCountry Liberal PartyNTAgainstNot Recorded
Pauline HansonSenatorPauline Hanson's One Nation PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Peter GeorgiouSenatorPauline Hanson's One Nation PartyWAForNot Recorded
Peter Whish-WilsonSenatorAustralian GreensTASForNot Recorded
Rachel SiewertSenatorAustralian GreensWAForNot Recorded
Rex PatrickSenatorCentre AllianceSAForNot Recorded
Richard ColbeckSenatorLiberal PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Richard Di NataleSenatorAustralian GreensVICForNot Recorded
Sarah Hanson-YoungSenatorAustralian GreensSAForNot Recorded
Scott RyanSenatorNot RecordedVICAgainstNot Recorded
Simon BirminghamSenatorLiberal PartySAAgainstNot Recorded
Slade BrockmanSenatorLiberal PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Stirling GriffSenatorCentre AllianceSAForNot Recorded
Tim StorerSenatorIndependentSAForNot Recorded

Coverage Notes: Individual votes are included only for matched named roll calls. Unlisted people have no inferred vote. Parties and state labels are those in the division source.

Reference: RUUV-XYPG-NH8M-ZCKJ