Public Concern: Parliamentary proposal recorded under Motions: Banking and Financial Services.
Requested Action: That the Senate: (a) notes that: (i) trust in banks is essential to the economy, (ii) trust in the banks has been undermined by adverse findings of the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, (iii) misconduct related to poor standards of mortgage lending affects all Australians and risks financial instability, (iv) concentration on mortgage lending makes the economy vulnerable to a downturn in the housing market, (v) reliance on overseas debt markets for short-term borrowing by the major banks, and contagion from overseas counterparties through trillions of dollars of derivatives related to mortgages, pose serious systemic risk, (vi) misconduct related to financial advice, small business lending, superannuation and insurance shows that the business model of major banks is based on exploitation rather than customer service, (vii) the integrated structure of banks facilitates misconduct due to the lack of transparency when traditional commercial banking is linked with investment banking, financial advice, wealth management, stockbroking, superannuation and insurance businesses, (viii) the integrated structure creates a conflict of interests because the lack of transparency enables banks to extract profits through cross-subsidies of various activities, and the indirect cost to retail superannuation members runs to many billions per year, (ix) the enormous profits extracted through the integrated structure entrenches the major banks as an effective cartel, preventing market competition and increasing concentration, and (x) the integrated structure puts bank deposits at risk as collateral for major banks' speculation in mortgage-backed securities and derivatives – this puts the real productive economy at unnecessary risk; and (b) calls on the Federal Government to reduce the conflicts of interests by legislating the structural separation of the banking system, where traditional commercial banking of taking deposits and making loans is separated from investment banking and all other financial services, including financial advice, wealth management, superannuation, stockbroking and insurance.
Effect On The Original Proposal: Recorded outcomes and any procedural decisions are shown separately for each question.
Original Question Vote: 2018-10-18 · Substantive Proposal · DEFEATED: 15 For, 31 Against
Debate Opportunity: The originating contribution and related proceedings are linked in Sources.
Original Proposal
Sponsors / Representatives: Pauline Hanson
Outcome: DEFEATED: 15 For, 31 Against
Type: Motion
Chamber: Senate
Jurisdiction: Australian Parliament, Australia
Recorded Date: 18/10/2018
Topics: Pauline Hanson; Motion; Motions
Votes And Procedural Actions
Substantive Proposal · Adopt Proposal
Date: 2018-10-18
Exact Question Put: That the Senate: (a) notes that: (i) trust in banks is essential to the economy, (ii) trust in the banks has been undermined by adverse findings of the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, (iii) misconduct related to poor standards of mortgage lending affects all Australians and risks financial instability, (iv) concentration on mortgage lending makes the economy vulnerable to a downturn in the housing market, (v) reliance on overseas debt markets for short-term borrowing by the major banks, and contagion from overseas counterparties through trillions of dollars of derivatives related to mortgages, pose serious systemic risk, (vi) misconduct related to financial advice, small business lending, superannuation and insurance shows that the business model of major banks is based on exploitation rather than customer service, (vii) the integrated structure of banks facilitates misconduct due to the lack of transparency when traditional commercial banking is linked with investment banking, financial advice, wealth management, stockbroking, superannuation and insurance businesses, (viii) the integrated structure creates a conflict of interests because the lack of transparency enables banks to extract profits through cross-subsidies of various activities, and the indirect cost to retail superannuation members runs to many billions per year, (ix) the enormous profits extracted through the integrated structure entrenches the major banks as an effective cartel, preventing market competition and increasing concentration, and (x) the integrated structure puts bank deposits at risk as collateral for major banks' speculation in mortgage-backed securities and derivatives – this puts the real productive economy at unnecessary risk; and
Result: DEFEATED: 15 For, 31 Against
Effect: This vote concerns the exact question and stage shown above.
Division / Decision Reference: Senate/2018-10-18/7
For: 15 · Against: 31
Named roll-call entries: 46. Names omitted from the recorded roll call have no inferred vote.
Showing 46 Of 46 Named Votes
| Senator / MP | Party At The Time | State / Electorate | Vote | Published Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alex GallacherSenator | Australian Labor Party | SA | Against | Not Recorded |
| Amanda StokerSenator | Liberal Party | QLD | Against | Not Recorded |
| Anne UrquhartSenator | Australian Labor Party | TAS | Against | Not Recorded |
| Anthony ChisholmSenator | Australian Labor Party | QLD | Against | Not Recorded |
| Barry O'SullivanSenator | National Party | QLD | For | Not Recorded |
| Catryna BilykSenator | Australian Labor Party | TAS | Against | Not Recorded |
| Concetta Fierravanti-WellsSenator | Liberal Party | NSW | Against | Not Recorded |
| David BushbySenator | Liberal Party | TAS | Against | Not Recorded |
| David LeyonhjelmSenator | Not Recorded | NSW | Against | Not Recorded |
| David SmithSenator | Australian Labor Party | ACT | Against | Not Recorded |
| Deborah O'NeillSenator | Australian Labor Party | NSW | Against | Not Recorded |
| Derryn HinchSenator | Not Recorded | VIC | Against | Not Recorded |
| Fraser AnningSenator | Not Recorded | QLD | For | Not Recorded |
| Gavin MarshallSenator | Australian Labor Party | VIC | Against | Not Recorded |
| Glenn SterleSenator | Australian Labor Party | WA | Against | Not Recorded |
| Jacinta CollinsSenator | Australian Labor Party | VIC | Against | Not Recorded |
| James McGrathSenator | Liberal National Party | QLD | Against | Not Recorded |
| James PatersonSenator | Liberal Party | VIC | Against | Not Recorded |
| Jane HumeSenator | Liberal Party | VIC | Against | Not Recorded |
| Janet RiceSenator | Australian Greens | VIC | For | Not Recorded |
| Jim MolanSenator | Liberal Party | NSW | Against | Not Recorded |
| John WilliamsSenator | National Party | NSW | Against | Not Recorded |
| Jonathon DuniamSenator | Liberal Party | TAS | Against | Not Recorded |
| Kristina KeneallySenator | Australian Labor Party | NSW | Against | Not Recorded |
| Larissa WatersSenator | Australian Greens | QLD | For | Not Recorded |
| Linda ReynoldsSenator | Liberal Party | WA | Against | Not Recorded |
| Lisa SinghSenator | Australian Labor Party | TAS | Against | Not Recorded |
| Louise PrattSenator | Australian Labor Party | WA | Against | Not Recorded |
| Mehreen FaruqiSenator | Australian Greens | NSW | For | Not Recorded |
| Mitch FifieldSenator | Liberal Party | VIC | Against | Not Recorded |
| Murray WattSenator | Australian Labor Party | QLD | Against | Not Recorded |
| Nick McKimSenator | Australian Greens | TAS | For | Not Recorded |
| Nigel ScullionSenator | Country Liberal Party | NT | Against | Not Recorded |
| Pauline HansonSenator | Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party | QLD | For | Not Recorded |
| Peter GeorgiouSenator | Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party | WA | For | Not Recorded |
| Peter Whish-WilsonSenator | Australian Greens | TAS | For | Not Recorded |
| Rachel SiewertSenator | Australian Greens | WA | For | Not Recorded |
| Rex PatrickSenator | Centre Alliance | SA | For | Not Recorded |
| Richard ColbeckSenator | Liberal Party | TAS | Against | Not Recorded |
| Richard Di NataleSenator | Australian Greens | VIC | For | Not Recorded |
| Sarah Hanson-YoungSenator | Australian Greens | SA | For | Not Recorded |
| Scott RyanSenator | Not Recorded | VIC | Against | Not Recorded |
| Simon BirminghamSenator | Liberal Party | SA | Against | Not Recorded |
| Slade BrockmanSenator | Liberal Party | WA | Against | Not Recorded |
| Stirling GriffSenator | Centre Alliance | SA | For | Not Recorded |
| Tim StorerSenator | Independent | SA | For | Not Recorded |
No named votes match this filter.
Coverage Notes: Individual votes are included only for matched named roll calls. Unlisted people have no inferred vote. Parties and state labels are those in the division source.
Reference: RUUV-XYPG-NH8M-ZCKJ