Alecomm · Parliamentary Accountability

Public View · Owner Sign-In

Renewable Energy

Public Concern: Parliamentary proposal recorded under Motions: Renewable Energy.

Requested Action: That the Senate— (a) notes that: (i) in July 2019, former Tasmanian senator and founder of the Australian Greens , Dr Bob Brown, stated 'The proposal to build 200 supersized wind turbines on Robbins Island cattle farm will be the death of a thousand cuts to the State's endangered shore birds', (ii) the Australian Greens: (A) have not opposed the Robbins Island Wind Farm, first proposed in 2013, even though the island is home to the Tasmanian Wedge-tailed Eagles, listed as endangered under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (the EPBC Act), (B) opposed the Adani coal project on the grounds that the Black-Throated Finch, listed as endangered under the EPBC Act , would become extinct if approval was given by the Queensland Government to the Carmichael coal mine, and (C) apply double standards in respect of species extinction, because they use an endangered species listing if it might stop a coal project proceeding, but not when an endangered species listing might stop a wind farm or solar farm project, (iii) the matter of Mr Hamish Cumming and others versus the Victorian Minister for Planning, a matter concerning brolgas (water birds) and the Golden Plains Wind Farm, has been listed for hearing in the Supreme Court of Victoria in October 2019, (iv) the Commonwealth and Queensland Governments spent more than $40 million on the Kogan Creek Solar Boost Project, which did not deliver one milliamp of power, before being closed, and (v) a new industry comprising a small number of environmental consultants or brokers, who commonly receive 5% of the project cost as a fee, now operates to obtain planning approval for overseas wind farm operators; and (b) calls on the Commonwealth Government to work with State Government Planning Ministers and their departments to be vigilant in making sure projects are viable and proper arms-length processes are followed when approving wind, solar and other renewable energy projects.

Effect On The Original Proposal: Recorded outcomes and any procedural decisions are shown separately for each question.

Original Question Vote: 2019-10-15 · Substantive Proposal · DEFEATED: 2 For, 53 Against

Debate Opportunity: The originating contribution and related proceedings are linked in Sources.

Original Proposal
That the Senate— (a) notes that: (i) in July 2019, former Tasmanian senator and founder of the Australian Greens , Dr Bob Brown, stated 'The proposal to build 200 supersized wind turbines on Robbins Island cattle farm will be the death of a thousand cuts to the State's endangered shore birds', (ii) the Australian Greens: (A) have not opposed the Robbins Island Wind Farm, first proposed in 2013, even though the island is home to the Tasmanian Wedge-tailed Eagles, listed as endangered under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (the EPBC Act), (B) opposed the Adani coal project on the grounds that the Black-Throated Finch, listed as endangered under the EPBC Act , would become extinct if approval was given by the Queensland Government to the Carmichael coal mine, and (C) apply double standards in respect of species extinction, because they use an endangered species listing if it might stop a coal project proceeding, but not when an endangered species listing might stop a wind farm or solar farm project, (iii) the matter of Mr Hamish Cumming and others versus the Victorian Minister for Planning, a matter concerning brolgas (water birds) and the Golden Plains Wind Farm, has been listed for hearing in the Supreme Court of Victoria in October 2019, (iv) the Commonwealth and Queensland Governments spent more than $40 million on the Kogan Creek Solar Boost Project, which did not deliver one milliamp of power, before being closed, and (v) a new industry comprising a small number of environmental consultants or brokers, who commonly receive 5% of the project cost as a fee, now operates to obtain planning approval for overseas wind farm operators; and (b) calls on the Commonwealth Government to work with State Government Planning Ministers and their departments to be vigilant in making sure projects are viable and proper arms-length processes are followed when approving wind, solar and other renewable energy projects.

Sponsors / Representatives: Pauline Hanson

Outcome: DEFEATED: 2 For, 53 Against

Type: Motion

Chamber: Senate

Jurisdiction: Australian Parliament, Australia

Recorded Date: 15/10/2019

Topics: Pauline Hanson; Motion; Motions

Votes And Procedural Actions

Substantive Proposal · Adopt Proposal

Date: 2019-10-15

Exact Question Put: That the Senate— (a) notes that: (i) in July 2019, former Tasmanian senator and founder of the Australian Greens, Dr Bob Brown, stated 'The proposal to build 200 supersized wind turbines on Robbins Island cattle farm will be the death of a thousand cuts to the State's endangered shore birds', (ii) the Australian Greens: (A) have not opposed the Robbins Island Wind Farm, first proposed in 2013, even though the island is home to the Tasmanian Wedge-tailed Eagles, listed as endangered under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (the EPBC Act), (B) opposed the Adani coal project on the grounds that the Black-Throated Finch, listed as endangered under the EPBC Act, would become extinct if approval was given by the Queensland Government to the Carmichael coal mine, and (C) apply double standards in respect of species extinction, because they use an endangered species listing if it might stop a coal project proceeding, but not when an endangered species listing might stop a wind farm or solar farm project,

Result: DEFEATED: 2 For, 53 Against

Effect: This vote concerns the exact question and stage shown above.

Division / Decision Reference: Senate/2019-10-15/3

For: 2 · Against: 53

Named roll-call entries: 55. Names omitted from the recorded roll call have no inferred vote.

Showing 55 Of 55 Named Votes

Senator / MPParty At The TimeState / ElectorateVotePublished Explanation
Alex AnticSenatorLiberal PartySAAgainstNot Recorded
Alex GallacherSenatorAustralian Labor PartySAAgainstNot Recorded
Amanda StokerSenatorLiberal PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Andrew BraggSenatorLiberal PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Anne RustonSenatorLiberal PartySAAgainstNot Recorded
Arthur SinodinosSenatorLiberal PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Carol BrownSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Catryna BilykSenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Claire ChandlerSenatorLiberal PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Concetta Fierravanti-WellsSenatorLiberal PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Cory BernardiSenatorNot RecordedSAAgainstNot Recorded
David VanSenatorLiberal PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Dean SmithSenatorLiberal PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Eric AbetzSenatorLiberal PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Gerard RennickSenatorLiberal PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Glenn SterleSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Helen PolleySenatorAustralian Labor PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Hollie HughesSenatorLiberal PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
James PatersonSenatorLiberal PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Jane HumeSenatorLiberal PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Jenny McAllisterSenatorAustralian Labor PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Jess WalshSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Jonathon DuniamSenatorLiberal PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Jordon Steele-JohnSenatorAustralian GreensWAAgainstNot Recorded
Katy GallagherSenatorAustralian Labor PartyACTAgainstNot Recorded
Larissa WatersSenatorAustralian GreensQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Louise PrattSenatorAustralian Labor PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Malarndirri McCarthySenatorAustralian Labor PartyNTAgainstNot Recorded
Malcolm RobertsSenatorPauline Hanson's One Nation PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Marielle SmithSenatorAustralian Labor PartySAAgainstNot Recorded
Marise PayneSenatorLiberal PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Matt O'SullivanSenatorLiberal PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Matthew CanavanSenatorLiberal National PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Mehreen FaruqiSenatorAustralian GreensNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Murray WattSenatorAustralian Labor PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Nick McKimSenatorAustralian GreensTASAgainstNot Recorded
Nita GreenSenatorAustralian Labor PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Paul ScarrSenatorLiberal PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Pauline HansonSenatorPauline Hanson's One Nation PartyQLDForNot Recorded
Perin DaveySenatorNational PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Peter Whish-WilsonSenatorAustralian GreensTASAgainstNot Recorded
Rachel SiewertSenatorAustralian GreensWAAgainstNot Recorded
Raff CicconeSenatorAustralian Labor PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Richard ColbeckSenatorLiberal PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded
Richard Di NataleSenatorAustralian GreensVICAgainstNot Recorded
Sam McMahonSenatorCountry Liberal PartyNTAgainstNot Recorded
Sarah Hanson-YoungSenatorAustralian GreensSAAgainstNot Recorded
Sarah HendersonSenatorLiberal PartyVICAgainstNot Recorded
Scott RyanSenatorNot RecordedVICAgainstNot Recorded
Slade BrockmanSenatorLiberal PartyWAAgainstNot Recorded
Sue LinesSenatorNot RecordedWAAgainstNot Recorded
Susan McDonaldSenatorNational PartyQLDAgainstNot Recorded
Tim AyresSenatorAustralian Labor PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Tony SheldonSenatorAustralian Labor PartyNSWAgainstNot Recorded
Wendy AskewSenatorLiberal PartyTASAgainstNot Recorded

Coverage Notes: Individual votes are included only for matched named roll calls. Unlisted people have no inferred vote. Parties and state labels are those in the division source.

Reference: S4WM-UEK6-THPD-MDET